How to Submit a Rearch Paper to a Journal
高铁什么东西不能带In the later stages of your doctoral studies in Mathematics, one of the important things you will need to do is to submit one or more papers to rearch journals for possible publication. You should do this as soon as your disrtation advir tells you that your rearch is ready for publication, but not before! If you are co-authoring a paper with your advir, then he or she may be handling the submission details as the nior co-author. If so, ask your advir to u the submission process to teach you how it is done, so you will be able to do this yourlf in the future. However, if you are submitting a paper as the sole or nior author, then you will need know how to handle this process yourlf. Over the years, there have been advanced graduate students who could have benefited from some general advice about the submission process. This letter has been written in the hope that you will navigate the publication process smoothly. Remember that any papers bad on your disrtation rearch should include a grateful acknowledgment - either in the introductory ction, as a footnote, or at the end. State that this work is part of your doctoral disrtation at Louisiana State University and thank your advir. Your acknowledgment of the role of your doctoral advir may help to insure that a journal editor takes your work riously, since it has at least pasd the scrutiny of your advir. If other mathematicians have helped, thank them too. Most mathematicians are generous about sharing their i
deas, but they will surely notice and remember if you fail to acknowledge them. This is good advice to remember for the future as well.
You should give careful thought to your paper's introduction. The introduction to your paper should explain clearly what your main results are and why they are interesting or important. The introduction should tell your audience how your mathematical work is related to recent rearch in the area. It is very important to properly reference the works. A referee for your paper may be chon from among the rearchers who work you cite. You would like the introduction to motivate readers to read more. Read the introductions from leading rearchers in your area to give you ideas about what you should include in your introduction.
Ask your advir read your entire paper and listen carefully to his or her suggestions. It takes much experience to know how to write well for a rearch journal. It is likely that you will need to go through veral thorough revisions before your advir is plead with your writing. Expect this to happen and learn from the process. It will benefit you for years to come.
动人故事
It is important that your paper be nt to referees with current experti in the field of your rearch. With this in mind, the first thing to do is to ask your advir to suggest a suitable journal and a suitabl
e editor to whom to nd your paper. Your advir may know that a certain journal is an active venue for publication in your field. Before you and your advir make a final choice of the journal to which you will submit your paper, you may be well-advid to check the backlog of the journals that you are considering. Especially during the early years of your career, you may have a practical need to get veral papers into print without very long delays.Backlog information is often available at the journals' websites, as explained below. Another uful type of information which is available is the Mathematics Citation Quotient(the ratio of the number citations to the number of papers in a given journal) which is available on MathSciNet through any LSU campus computer,or from home through PAWS and the LSU Library resources.For instance, in 2004 the MCQ of Transactions of the AMS is listed at a bit more than 0.6, whereas for the Journal of the AMS it is above 2. Another citation index is available through the LSU Library. From the LSU Libraries Indexes and Databas page, which is available through your PAWS account even from home, lect Web of Knowledge in the Frequently Ud Databas menu.Then lect Journal Citation Reports from the menu at the top of the ISI Web of Knowledge page.
红色家园
Many journals have websites, which you should visit to read their instructions for authors.
For example the AMS Journals u this page: Information for Authors. Here is a link to a page for Tra
nsactions of the American Mathematical Society: Submissions to Transactions. You will note
that some editors favor electronic submission, some favor paper, and some want both. You will probably find a list of members of the journal's editorial board, as one finds at List of Transactions Editors for example. Be sure to discuss with your advir which editor would be the best one to receive your submission. You may also find a page listing style files for that journal which you can download: Authors Package for Transactions. You will e also a link for the Backlog Information for Transactions of the AMS. Other journals provide similar information. For example, here is a link for the Backlog Information for the Journal of the AMS. A number of mathematics journals accept submission of articles from listings which authors can place at the Mathematics arXiv. Once you have lected a journal, check the requirements for publication in that journal, with regard to style, type and length of papers published, etc, to make sure you get the things right. When you nd your paper, you will include a brief cover-letter to the editor. Make sure you know how to write a formal, polite letter. You should ask your advir for suggestions about this letter and also to review what you have written in the letter before nding it. Your letter should state that you are submitting a paper to Journal X bad on the rearch which is or will be part of your doctoral disrtation in mathematics at LSU. If it is in an accepted disrtation, say so. State that your advir, whom you n真丝布料
ame, has recommended submission to Journal X and to this particular editor. Some authors include a ntence to describe briefly the specialized topic of the submitted paper.For example:This paper is an application of the reprentation theory of unipotent algebraic groups to a problem in spectral geometry.Each editor will have either a mental or a written list of experts in many specialties.Your description,together with the title,abstract, introduction, and bibliography of your paper can help the editor to lect a suitable referee from his list.
耳聋的原因
If you have already received your doctorate and are submitting from your first job away from LSU, be sure to write on the correct letterhead stationery of your new institution. Failure to do this became a problem for a PhD graduate of this department years ago. This graduate had earned a prestigious postdoctoral rearch job at a Group-1 Math Department (the highest group in the AMS classification of university mathematics departments). Yet this very talented graduate wrote a letter of submission without any of the information mentioned in the preceding paragraphs. The letter was written on a plain sheet of white paper, with no mention of holding a PhD or any job in mathematics! The paper was summarily rejected without being nt to a referee.
六甲人
We would all like to believe that every idea will be judged fairly on its own merit. But the fact is that editors and referees are busy people. Editors don't want to bother their referees by asking them to w
aste time reading junk. And people do sometimes make quick judgments bad on appearances, even if that is not the right thing to do. So this graduate was given the name of another suitable editor for the same journal, and was advid to write the letter on the letterhead stationery of the Group-1 math department for which the graduate worked, and to sign with the title of the named postdoctoral rearch job held. We won't divulge the name the graduate involved,but the cond letter was signed in this format:"Dr.Alpha B.Gamma,Coveted Assistant Professor, Famous University." With this cond submission, the paper was accepted by the same prestigious rearch journal which had rejected the same paper shortly before. No revisions had taken place.
It is reasonable for a period of about 6 months to be required for the refereeing to be completed. If the time goes much longer than this, it would be appropriate to nd a respectful note to the Editor to ask whether any feedback had arrived from the referee. The Editor will likely nd a reminder to the referee, who may have t the paper aside for a few weeks, perhaps forgetting about it entirely becau of the passage of time.
There are many kinds of feedback which you may eventually receive. The referee may have questions about the mathematics in its details,and the will need to be answered clearly, perhaps through revisions of the submission.You may be asked to make certain types of revisions and then r
e-submit either to the same journal or to another one which could be more suitable. It is important not to become discouraged if you need to make revisions or to submit to
another journal. This does not necessarily mean you have written a poor paper. Your paper may be excellent even if it is rejected outright. Here is an example from the 1930s.男生喜欢女生的表现
Prof. Eugene Wigner, the Nobel Prize winning physicist, ud to spend many winters during his lengthy retirement from Princeton visiting his former students at LSU. Becau Prof. Wigner enjoyed mathematics, he often spent time at the Math Department, conversing with mathematics faculty members.When Wigner was young he had written a paper called On the unitary reprentations of the inhomogeneous Lorentz group. He had submitted it to Transactions of the American Mathematical Society,which rejected it as being of insufficiently general interest. Wigner discusd this with his friend, John von Neumann, who suggested submitting the paper to him for Annals of Mathematics, of which von Neumann was an editor. Annals published it, and many years later Wigner received a letter from the AMS. It said that the Society had conducted a study to identify the most-cited rearch papers in twentieth century mathematics, and Wigner's paper mentioned above was one of the.
望海潮朗读
You will receive much advice during your career as a mathematician giving you good reasons to publish your rearch. You will decide for yourlf what to do and why you do it. But here is a good reason which is sometimes overlooked. If you have discovered something which you find interesting, when you publish it you are sharing it with others. That is a good thing to do, for the same reason it is good to teach mathematics. Publishing your rearch is an especially personal kind of sharing,becau it is your own contribution.And when you find that another mathematician shares your interest, this will be very satisfying for you.
